|
areuonsomething.com
The
5th Annual Jammy Awards
(Which
in just five years has managed to not actually be annual)
A Review by Mike D'Ariano
The Theater
at Madison Square Garden
April 26, 2005
Song
of the Year: Umphrey's McGee, "In the Kitchen."
Lifetime Achievement: Buddy Guy
New Groove of the Year: Benevento/Russo Duo
Tour of the Year: Phish, Summer 2004
Download of the Year: The Dead 6/12/04, Bonnaroo, Manchester, TN
DVD of the Year: Phish, IT
Archival Live Album of the Year: Jerry Garcia, After Midnight Kean College,
2/28/80
Mimi Fishman Memorial Community Service Award: HeadCount
Studio Album of the Year: Gov't Mule, Deja Voodoo
Live Album of the Year: Keller Williams, Stage
Live Performance of the Year: Phil Lesh & Friends, 12/19/04
Grahamy Jammy: Ken Hayes
As
soon as we got to the venue, I had doubts about it. The Theater at Madison
Square Garden is not Roseland, and it's damn sure not The Wetlands. Even
though the Jammys had been held in the room on one prior occasion, it
just didn't seem like a comfortable fit. There's something about the concept
of guys in tuxedos walking around the room selling cans of Budweiser for
six dollars apiece to guys wearing homemade hemp pants that just doesn't
sit right with me.
My doubt was reinforced, as I said, as soon as we got there. The first
thing I heard was one of the security guards, who all were wearing those
phony old Hollywood bellhop uniforms like you see in Disney World, making
an announcement to the good folks on line. The announcement was, and I
assure you I'm not making this up, "Ok guys, now you know, you can't
bring anything inside." No you can't bring food, or drinks, or drugs.
You can't bring anything inside. I was glad I got to bring in my notebook,
after the announcement, I wasn't sure if paper was a banned substance.
Following the notification that nothing was allowed, a small battalion
of guards began making their way through the crowd with handheld metal
detectors, screening people at random. After getting my phone, palm pilot,
keys, wallet, and change out of my pockets, I was of course not wanded
down. As we finally entered the theatre, I found myself wondering what
all the security was about. Then I realized it made perfect sense considering
the unspeakably violent crowd that is usually attracted by acts like The
Grateful Dead, Mavis Staples and of course, Huey Lewis.
Anyway, we got inside and headed down to the general admission floor section.
It didn't take long to make the executive decision that we would do everything
in our power to obtain some type of seat for the majority of the five
hour event. We walked up to the "tapers section" a.k.a. the
first row of seats beyond the standing room only section, and sat down.
Apparently, the deal was that if you asked if you could sit there, the
usher would tell you no and kick you out, but if you just sat down, as
we did, no one would bother you. So there we sat, watching people getting
thrown out of the section that we shouldn't have been sitting in and waited
for the show to begin.
At eight o'clock sharp, the music began with the appearance of "washboard
man." Washboard man, who actually turned out to be the drummer of
the North Mississippi All-Stars, was joined almost immediately on stage
by North Mississippi, with Chris Myers from Umphrey's McGee on drums.
They played one song in this configuration and then Myers left. Washboard
man took to the drums and Mavis Staples, of The Staples Singers, joined
the band on voice.
Mavis was awesome. She sang "Freedom Highway" and the whole
room marched along with her down that road. This marked the first great
moment of the 2005 Jammy Awards. It was followed by a slight disappointment.
The disappointment was not Buddy Guy who joined North Mississippi next
. . . that was actually pretty great. The disappointment was that Mavis
left after only one song. My experience with Jammy's past has always been
that artists would pair up and jam together for a while. I've never seen
a collaboration last for just one tune. Bummer.
As
I mentioned, Buddy Guy, the blues legend and recent inductee to the Rock
and Roll Hall of Fame, took the stage next. Whoa! Buddy's guitar was so
raw I felt like it might cut me in half. What an incredible tone. It really
tears through the bullshit and declares that this guy is the real deal.
They played the Muddy Waters tune, "Got My Mojo Workin" and
then, DAMN IT, Buddy Guy left the stage after just one song. It was the
second time in as many songs that I wanted to see more of what was going
on and it was abruptly cut short. I hoped that wasn't the new format of
the show. It proved not to be.
At this point, there was a quick break in the action while producer Peter
Shapiro welcomed us to the show and said he was glad that they pulled
the event off with no sponsors. I'm sure the good folks at American Spirit,
D'Addario, Evans, Planet Waves, Linden Travel, Red Hook, Palm Pictures,
A View Of You, eMusic, Techistry and the rest of the show's sponsors which
I found on the Jammys website under the heading "Sponsors,"
were happy to hear him say that. Anyway, he then invited Phil Lesh, the
Grateful Dead's bassist and host of the show, to the stage. Phil said
hi, and announced the next musical performance.
Yonder Mountain String Band with Bruce Hornsby and Vince Herman, did absolutely
nothing for me. It was one of only two sections of the evening that I
didn't enjoy; the other, which I'll get to, was actually one step worse
because not only did I not enjoy it, I found it actively irritating. I'd
like to blame my dissatisfaction with Yonder/Hornsby/ Herman on the fact
that the sound was terrible, complete with a constant buzz, a few gunshot-like
pops, and a keyboard that was completely inaudible for an entire half
of the set. But honestly, I think the lack of energy following two great
high intensity performances was more to blame than anything. Onwards.
Up
next was the beginning of the award show side of the Jammys. Okay, lets
be honest people, up next was the beginning of the self-serving bullshit
side of the Jammys that no one on earth cares about other than the people
giving out the awards and the people getting them. Am I just cynical?
I think not. Case in point: Phil Lesh who gave out the first award, held
up the award at one point and said "This is cool, I've never seen
one of these." Phil has won at least three of the awards to date,
getting at least one at each of the past three Jammy Awards. EVEN THE
PEOPLE WINNING THESE THINGS DON'T CARE!! But I digress, the awards are
part of the show and I'll report on them accordingly. The first award
was for best song. Umphrey's McGee won for their tune, "In The Kitchen."
Dean
Budnick, editor of the Relix-owned website Jambands.com, took the podium
next and announced that it was time to hand out the lifetime achievement
award. A hush fell over the crowd. The recipient of the Lifetime Achievement
Award for 2005 had been kept a big secret. All the press for the show would
run down the line-up and then add the as yet to be announced Lifetime Achievement
award winner. In the past, the announcement was made early, and for at least
the past two Jammy's, the winner headlined the show. It was odd that they
were not telling anyone who it was this time around. As he was in town the
night of the awards, there had been much speculation that Bob Dylan was
going to receive the award, and they were keeping it a secret at his request
so as not to hurt ticket sales of his shows at the Beacon. Alas, this was
not to be. The top secret recipient of the Lifetime Achievement Award was
. . . Buddy Guy. What? Buddy Guy? But he's been on the ads for this show
for months, and they all said "plus the as yet to be announced Lifetime
Achievement Award winner." It was simultaneously pleasing since Buddy
surely deserves the award, and would more than likely now play a little
bit more for us, but also disappointing because the audience was promised
a surprise and wasn't given one.
In my mind, one of two things happened. Either, the Jammys were trying to
secure a big name to accept the award, like Dylan, and it fell apart at
the last minute so they just gave it to Guy, or they had this planned all
along and just screwed over the fans in an attempt to sell out the room,
which, if that was the plan, did not work. I would bet it was the former,
since the Jammys seem to be fairly fan friendly, but it seems like we'll
never know the truth behind the move.
Anyway, Buddy graciously accepted his award and made a great speech about
how guys like Muddy Waters, Jimmy Reed and T-Bone Walker really deserved
the award and he considered it theirs as well as his. Then he strapped on
his guitar and kicked off what to me was the highlight of the show; a jam
session featuring Guy and John Mayer on guitar, ?uestlove of The Roots on
drums, and Phil Lesh on bass.
The quartet played as if they'd been in the same band for years and ripped
through the blues classics "Hoochie Coochie Man", "Stormy
Monday" and "Rock Me Baby". The biggest surprise was when
Guy and Mayer started battling on guitar, and Mayer held his own with the
legend! Who the hell knew that guy could do anything other than the fluff
pop he's known for? Apparently, Buddy Guy did. At one point he said Mayer
was "the kind of guy who could keep the blues alive." I was impressed
and clearly had been underestimating John's ability.
It was also a cool little bonus to see John Mayer jamming with ?uestlove;
a collaboration that hadn't to my knowledge actually existed in real life,
but had occurred during a comedy sketch on the Chapelle's Show.
Two more awards came next. The Duo won the Best New Groove Award and Phish
won the Best Tour award. As Mike Gordon was accepting Phish's award, I began
to ponder the fact that the line-up of the show had been announced a month
and a half before the fan-based internet voting for the awards concluded,
yet so far everyone who had won an award, had been on the show. As the night
progressed, there were only two awards which were won by artists not performing
at the event, and one of those was won by Jerry Garcia. In case you didn't
know, he's dead . . . but I'm sure he was grateful.
The suspicions I was harboring and will not say out loud here, were increased
when Keller Williams, who was at the event, beat out Widespread Panic, who
were not. When Keller Williams plays in New York, he plays in a club the
holds roughly 1,000 people. The last time Panic were in town they sold about
40,000 tickets when they sold out Madison Square Garden for two consecutive
nights. 40,000 fans vs. 1,000 fans, and the little guy wins. Seems a little
too David and Goliath to be believable, but what do I know?
Now, I'm almost 2,000 words into this review, and I've actually only covered
the first hour of what was to be a five hour concert! I think I have to
pick up the pace a little. Let's get a few of the performances out of the
way, chronology be damned!
Ryan Adams was the first and only act of the night not to be involved in
a major collaboration. He and his band, the Cardinals, played two songs
and then invited Phil Lesh to join them on a mini-Dead jam of "Wharf
Rat/Bird Song". The Dead thing was interesting, the rest kinda wasn't.
Oh and Adams has a new look . . . Junkie. Interestingly enough as I write
this, about a month later, it was just announced that Ryan Adams would be
touring as part of Phil Lesh and Friends in the coming months. I guess they
hit it off.
Keller
Williams and ?uestlove did some really interesting stuff together which
was quite enjoyable, until Nellie McKay joined them and provided the one
moment of the entire night that I just couldn't stomach. I went to the men's
room. Taking a leak proved to be much more enjoyable than listening to the
next big thing absolutely butcher a Dylan song and then babble on for a
few other nails on the chalkboard tunes.
Travis Tritt and the Disco Biscuits doing what Phil Lesh described as "Electronic
Country" wasn't nearly as awkward as it sounds. In fact, it was pretty
cool, and Travis came off great. It was no weirder than the 2004 Jammys
collaboration between the Biscuits and old school rapper, Slick Rick.
Patti Smith would have been great if she showed up, as she was supposed
to, but she didn't, so she wasn't.
Sinead
O'Conner who didn't show up the first time I was supposed to see her,
which was coincidentally the same day I did see Patti Smith for the first
time, performed twice. Once with Huey Lewis, Mavis Staples and Umphrey's
McGee which was really pleasurable - they did things like "The Weight"
and "I'll Take You There" - and once later in the night with
Burning Spear, Medeski Martin and Wood, and the Anti-Balas Horns which
was kinda pleasurable, but way too long. The Sinead/Burning Spear thing
consisted of not one, not two, but five different reggae songs, before
everyone on stage along with Luther Dickenson, Les Claypool, ?uestlove
and a few others, tore into the Hendrix classic "Crosstown Traffic."
Everyone's favorite pope hating skinhead did provide the most awkward
moment of the night when she asked Burning Spear to begin the song "Jah
No Dead" again because they were in "the wrong key". Sounded
to me like he was just singing and she was just being way too full of
herself. But again, what do I know?
Now, while "Crosstown Traffic" was actually the finale of the
show, it wasn't the highlight. If that distinction doesn't go to the Buddy
Guy/Phil Lesh/?uestlove/John Mayer jam from earlier in the night, it definitely
goes to the jam between The Duo, with Mike Gordon of Phish, who were joined
by Phil Lesh, Les Claypool, Gabby La La for Claypool's tune "D's
Diner." If you know anything about this genre of music, you know
that seeing a three way bass off between Phil Lesh, Les Claypool and Mike
Gordon, is a once in a lifetime experience. It lived up to it's potential
and more or less stole the show.
That's it for the music.
The other moment that I found interesting was when Headcount won the Community
Service Award. Since Headcount, like many leftist organizations, failed
to swing the 2004 presidential election even after giving it all their
stoned little minds could muster, the "we changed the world"
speech stayed in the guy's pocket and the "Headcount wasn't about
the election" speech came out. He actually said that! "Headcount
wasn't about the election." I have just one question for Headcount
guy: Your sole purpose was registering people to VOTE and when the election
ended you all but disappeared. What the hell did you think it was about?
Fuckin' hippies.
Well that's about it. The show overall was fantastic, and I had a ball.
The only thing I have left to mention, is an idea I had for next year's
Jammy Awards. I got the idea when I noticed that one of the two guys in
front of me was wearing a Woodstock jacket and the other was wearing a
Slayer jacket. What the show really needs is a little metal to shake things
up. Just about every other genre from Rap to Bluegrass is accounted for.
How about next year you guys have the ultimate unexpected collaboration
and put some Death Metal band . . . say, Morbid Angel on stage with a
gospel group like the Blind Boys of Alabama! It would be incredible. You
could bill it as a God vs. The Devil, then rig it so God wins, and finally
- this is the kicker - give God the lifetime achievement award!! It would
be the biggest thing in the history of music! Plus, it would be interesting
to see who he thanked, since most people that win these corny-ass awards
tend to thank him first and foremost.
But then again, what do I know?
|